A Lingering Case of Indigestion

The Daily · · 8 min read

Good afternoon, everyone. Today:

  1. Council second guesses decision to change USD/GSD property tax rates
  2. The state legislature passed a bill that will change law enforcement in Downtown Nashville
  3. Waymo & Waze launch pilot program to identify potholes

And much more!

Terrorism in America

Join us Thursday, April 16th for a discussion with domestic terrorism expert Kyle Shideler as we dig into the federal government's response to the Charlie Kirk assassination and what it means for us here locally. (Buy Ticket)

New Council Watch Features We've added additional features to Council Watch. In addition to who's funding your councilmember, you can now see how they vote and who they vote with most frequently. (Take a Look)

The council’s heartburn over last budget season is back—with a bite.

On Tuesday, the Metro Council passed a resolution requesting additional research into tax rates and service levels within the Urban Services District (USD) and General Services District (GSD), aiming to ensure taxpayers across Davidson County are treated equitably.

Traditionally, USD residents have paid higher tax rates in exchange for additional services—such as trash and recycling pickup, increased police presence, and enhanced street cleaning. But after last year’s budget adjustments, that gap narrowed dramatically. Now, many GSD residents are paying nearly the same rate as their USD counterparts without receiving the same level of services.

The shift came after the council implemented changes recommended by a years-long study. “As a result, the difference between the tax rates in the GSD and USD went from 33.2 cents to 3.2 cents,” explained Sponsor Jason Spain during this week's meeting.

Councilmember Tonya Hancock expressed the growing frustration among GSD residents, who feel they’re being asked to subsidize the Urban Services District. “I currently pay only—what is it—three cents less in tax than those in the USD, but I also pay for my trash and my recycling and my street lights,” she shared.

Background

The current GSD/USD setup is a relic of the old city–county split between services, which merged when Nashville and Davidson County were consolidated into a single government in the 1960s.

The sharp change in rates for FY 2026 came after Raftelis Financial Consultants concluded its USD/GSD Study last April.

Metro hired the firm to answer a pretty simple question: Are Nashville taxpayers in the USD and GSD paying for the services they actually receive?

It’s still unclear exactly how much taxpayers shelled out for the original study.

During this week’s meeting, Councilmember Emily Benedict attempted to defer the new resolution, citing the lack of a fiscal note outlining the cost of further analysis.

“I think if we're going to look for a price, we need to look for the price the other study cost,” said Councilmember Jeff Eslick, who opposed the deferral. “It had no data. It was basically just splitting the math evenly.”

What’s Next?

Councilmember Erin Evans also urged colleagues to act sooner rather than later, noting that any future rate adjustments will take time to implement.

“We need to tell people the truth,” said Councilmember Eslick, highlighting that Metro encouraged the blatantly inequitable change. “We are actually going to pay the same amount sooner or later and not get the same amount of services.”

If the council decides to make an adjustment to the USD/GSD rates, it isn’t coming any time soon. Spain’s resolution is nonbinding and primarily signals the intent of the council. Any additional study would require a separate vote, dedicated funding, and sufficient time to produce findings before any policy changes could be considered.

TERRORISM IN AMERICA

Domestic Threats to Americans Following the assassination of Charlie Kirk, the Trump administration declared its intent to counter domestic terrorism and organized political violence.​

These efforts have been ongoing and recently bore some fruit, including major federal convictions and an upcoming international summit focused on countering the left-wing movement Antifa and other groups.​

Join us to learn from an expert in the field on domestic threats to the American people, Kyle Shideler, and what the Trump administration's efforts mean for Nashville.

Buy Ticket

This event is for the benefit of The Pamphleteer, Nashville, and priced with that in mind. Bard-level subscribers receive free admittance.

BLURBS

🚔 New Sheriff In Town Yesterday, the state legislature passed a bill that will change law enforcement in Downtown Nashville. HB2366 / SB2157 creates a new state-controlled framework for Tourism Development Zones (TDZ) in Tennessee. There are currently eight TDZs, including areas in Memphis, Knoxville, Music City, and others.

State Oversight The legislation empowers Tennessee's Department of Tourist Development and Department of Economic and Community Development to set rules for TDZs that can override local laws, with the goal of protecting and boosting economic activity in those areas. This includes guidelines for street access near businesses, loitering, and cleanliness.

State Law Enforcement The bill also empowers the Tennessee Highway Patrol (THP) to step in directly and police the areas alongside local authorities. Going forward, this means that the THP has the power to arrest, carry a firearm, and investigate crime within TDZs to potentially address things like street congestion and homeless encampments.

Why Does The State Want This Authority? Tourism Development Zones keep a percentage of taxes that would normally be due to the state. The local government is supposed to reinvest that money back into the tourist area to promote economic growth.

During its final vote in the state senate, bill sponsor Bo Watson (R-Hixon) explained that the state has a vested interest in protecting the economic viability of TDZs, arguing that significant investment in those areas could otherwise have been distributed statewide.

“When local governments, for reasons outside what's enumerated in this bill, choose to close streets and prohibit the movement of commerce, it has an adverse effect on state government, and therefore the state should have an opportunity to intervene,” concluded Watson. “And that's what the bill does.”
DAVIS HUNT & MEGAN PODSIEDLIK

METRO COUNCIL WATCH

New Council Watch Features We've added additional features to Council Watch. In addition to who's funding your councilmember, you can now see how they vote and who they vote with most frequently. (Take a Look)

HEADLINES

  • Waymo & Waze launches pothole program.

    The driverless ride-share company, which just started offering rides to the public in Nashville, has launched a pilot program with Waze to identify potholes.

    NBJ
  • TDOT announces a 10-year plan to improve safety on Nolensville Pike.

    The Tennessee Department of Transportation is already widening the road from two lanes to five lanes, adding turn lanes, sidewalks, and bike lanes. This week, an additional state-funded 10-year plan was also announced, which aims to stretch improvements all the way to the city of Nolensville. TDOT predicts traffic on Nolensville Pike will nearly double over the next 20 years. (NewsChannel 5)

  • Metro to Launch Countywide Ecological Study

    The Metro Planning Department is preparing to undertake an 18-month project to assess Davidson County’s environment and strategize ways to address the issues identified in the study. The upcoming study—called the Ecological Conservation Strategy—is set to launch April 17.

    Scene
  • TN legislature passes bill granting Duck, Buffalo rivers scenic protections.

    The bill bars mining, commercial timber harvesting, and landfills within two miles of designated scenic rivers.

    Lookout
  • Lee pushes to ‘break the seal’ to generate transportation funding

    . In his 2026 budget proposal, Governor Bill Lee included $25 million in new, recurring General Fund revenue for the Tennessee Department of Transportation to address infrastructure needs. This is part of a larger proposed $425 million transportation package that also includes $400 million in one-time funds. In recent budget hearings, Finance Commissioner Jim Bryson pointed out that sourcing the new money from the general fund marks a departure from how the state has gone about paying for road construction.

    State Affairs
  • Forbes

    ' ‘New Ivies’ list includes Vanderbilt among top 10 private universities. The New Ivies list consists of 10 “outstanding” public universities and 10 private schools that are outpacing the Ivy League in the “eyes of employers.” Forbes said that each of the 20 schools on the list reports that AI fluency has become a critical learning outcome.

    WSMV
Hosted by the Delphica Society, the event aims to raise money to support Zimmerman's legal fight against the Knoxville Symphony. (Buy ticket)

DEVELOPMENT

  • Utility giant buys $65 million in Nashville real estate, including prime Germantown site

    NBJ
  • Downtown Franklin building home to Gray's on Main sells for $5.65 million

    NBJ
  • Fairgrounds apartment property sells for $54.4M

    Post
  • Schermerhorn site eyed for two digital signs

    Post
  • Berry Hill property listed for $1.39M

    Post

THINGS TO DO

Tonight Fri, Apr 10

ShowVenueTimePriceLink
Guerrero Conducts PétrouchkaSchermerhown Symphony Center7:30p$29+Info for Guerrero Conducts Pétrouchka

🪕 Field Medic @ The Blue Room, 7p, $26, Info

🪕 Fast Track @ Station Inn, 9p, Info

🪕 The Cowpokes @ Acme Feed & Seed, 12p, Free, Info

🎸 Kelley’s Heroes @ Robert’s Western World, 6:30p, Free, Info

Saturday

ShowVenueTimePriceLink
The Avett Brothers and Mike Patton present AVTT/PTTNThe Pinnacle8p$79+Info for The Avett Brothers and Mike Patton present AVTT/PTTN
Delphica Society Presents: A Fundraiser in Support of Mr. James Zimmerman7p$100+Info for Delphica Society Presents: A Fundraiser in Support of Mr. James Zimmerman
The Clash & The Replacements Tribute Show featuring: Tommy Gun & Hip ReplacementsThe Basement7p$12.85Info for The Clash & The Replacements Tribute Show featuring: Tommy Gun & Hip Replacements
MoonchildBrooklyn Bowl Nashville8p$48.80+Info for Moonchild
Redd KrossThe Blue Room$32.51Info for Redd Kross
Girl TonesThe Basement9p$12.85Info for Girl Tones
Special ConsensusStation Inn9pInfo for Special Consensus
Kelley’s HeroesRobert’s Western World6:30pFreeInfo for Kelley’s Heroes

Sunday

ShowVenueTimePriceLink
Bluegrass Jam+ a night for musicians and singers from all over the world to gather and enjoy making music togetherStation Inn7pFreeInfo for Bluegrass Jam
Sundays Between with Easy Green+ a bluegrass celebration of the music of the Grateful DeadTennessee Brew Works1pInfo for Sundays Between with Easy Green

Today's newsletter is brought to you by Davis Hunt, Megan Podsiedlik, and Camelia Brennan.

The rest of today's issue

Keep reading: free, just your email

You keep coming back. It's free; we only ask for your email.

Headlines, tools, development and tonight's shows are one step away. Tomorrow's Daily comes with it.

Newsletters

Comments

Bards join the discussion. Everyone can read it.

Like what we do? Forward us to a friend.

Members

Get in the roomYou're in the room

Bards get free, privileged admittance to Pamphleteer events, and a say in the comments under every story. The membership pays for The Pamphleteer's reporting, member features and events.

The Bard$50 a monthThat's you

Become a BardYour membership