Two blurred figures trading punches against a green and blue background, glass flying between them

A Slow Motion Fistfight

The Daily · · 6 min read

Good afternoon, everyone. Today:

  1. Metro Legal says a smaller council has to go before the voters
  2. DesJarlais concedes District 4 to Broderick
  3. A bill to make it official: nonalcoholic beer is fine behind the wheel

And much more!

Metro Legal says a smaller council has to go before the voters

Looks like there’s going to be a slow motion fistfight over how the city gets into compliance with the new state law capping the council at twenty members, which the Tennessee Supreme Court upheld November 2nd, the day before Election Day.

Friday, the Charter Revision Committee got together for a special called meeting on the matter.

New Metro Legal Director Tyler Yarbro, wife of state Sen. Jeff Yarbro (D-Nashville), debuted and opened things up, opining that the council must receive approval from a majority of Davidson County voters via a referendum on the new number.

The state law, as rewritten by the legislature in May, says Metro’s council “must not exceed 20 voting members” but leaves the how to the council. It directs the body to “take any legislative action required to effectuate this section by resolution receiving an affirmative majority vote of those present and voting, regardless of any provision of a charter or private act to the contrary.”

Yarbro’s argument hinges on what that last clause leaves out: state law. A state statute says no metro charter amendment can take effect until it goes before voters. As Yarbro argues, because the council’s size is defined in the charter, changing it requires a charter amendment.

On the legislative front, House Majority Leader William Lamberth told the Banner the change should be made “well ahead of the next election.”

House Speaker Cameron Sexton told us last week, “If they ultimately still use the excuse ‘of not enough time,’ we have staff that will draw it for them in a more timely manner.”

Asked about the legislature drawing the lines itself, Yarbro said it “seems difficult to imagine a way for them to just draw our maps and for that to be a constitutional act.”

The charter normally requires amendments to wait for a regular August or November election, but Yarbro said the state law offers “a path for flexibility” toward a special election. Candidate petitions for the August 2027 races become available March 22, which she called “a key date.”

Yarbro said the council must pick one configuration and put it to voters as a straight yes-or-no question. The obvious question that follows: what if voters say no?

Metro “would have to continue its efforts to comply,” Yarbro said. Later, she conceded, “I confess that this could be a conundrum.” And if the council is still at 40 when the August 2027 election arrives, she said, it “should continue as a 40-member body.”

The committee will pick up the discussion about next steps before tomorrow night’s council meeting.

SOMETHING TO DO

American Scapegoat: Derek Chauvin and the Future of the West, presented by Passage Press: Thursday, Dec. 3, 7pm, Nashville. Click for tickets.

📚 American Scapegoat release event Passage Press hosts author TJ Harker and special guests in Nashville on Thursday, Dec. 3, to celebrate the release of his book American Scapegoat: How a Corrupt Justice System Sacrificed Derek Chauvin to the Mob.

A panel will discuss the Chauvin trial and its impact on criminal justice and social life in the U.S. VIP guests get a private happy hour with the panel and the author at 6pm; general admission starts at 7pm, with a cocktail hour and signed books after the talk. The address comes with registration. (Tickets here)

HEADLINES

  • DesJarlais concedes District 4 to Broderick

    Rep. Scott DesJarlais conceded the newly redrawn 4th Congressional District to Democrat Victoria Broderick of Fayetteville today, after Nashville counted its roughly 700 provisional ballots. Broderick won by 280 votes, 95,585 to 95,305. Two years ago, DesJarlais beat her by 40 points; Trump carried the district by about 24 points in 2024.

    Tennessee Lookout
  • Metro’s buyout gets its first vote as the health fund runs dry

    Mayor O’Connell’s plan to pay retirement-eligible Metro employees $1,000 per year of service to retire goes before the council Tuesday. SEIU Local 205 President Jessica Stewart backs it for some workers but worries about departments that are already thin. Meanwhile, Finance Director Jenneen Reed says Metro’s self-insurance fund fell from $96 million in June 2024 to $21 million this June and is expected to go negative by year’s end; she’ll ask the council for $20 million to $25 million to cover it.

    Banner
  • A Tennessee bill would make it official: nonalcoholic beer is fine behind the wheel

    Rep. Kevin Raper (R-Cleveland) introduced a bill exempting nonalcoholic beer (any beverage with less than 0.5% ABV) from Tennessee’s open container laws, meaning you’ll be able to “drink and drive” with a frosty beverage. “I know of nowhere in the nation that a bill like this has passed,” Raper told The Tennessee Journal. “I hope we’re the cutting edge.”

    State Affairs

OPEN CONTAINER LAWS BY STATE

Map of open-container laws by state as of 2006: most states meet the federal standard; Tennessee, Louisiana and Alaska have weaker laws, with Tennessee letting passengers drink; Missouri, Arkansas, Mississippi, West Virginia, Virginia, Connecticut, Delaware and D.C. have none

🍻 Drink and Ride As of 2006, 40 states met the federal standard for open containers in vehicles. Tennessee, Louisiana and Alaska had laws that fell short of it, and seven states plus D.C. had no open-container law at all.

States that don’t comply have part of their federal highway construction funds moved into road safety programs instead. Tennessee still bans open containers only for drivers, so it has 2.5% of its yearly federal highway construction money moved to safety programs, or about $18 million a year at last count.

DEVELOPMENT

Rendering of Oracle's East Bank campus: a creek lined with trees and boulders running between office buildings, under a pedestrian bridge
  • Oracle broke ground on its world headquarters on the East Bank: a 78-acre campus on the old industrial riverfront, designed by Foster + Partners, with more than 1,900 trees and $175 million in public infrastructure, including a pedestrian bridge over the Cumberland. The first buildings are set to open in 2030.

    City Now Next
  • TDOT gave the James Robertson Parkway job to Tennessee contractor Wright Brothers. Work starts in spring 2027, and the bridge closes that summer for about two years while crews lower the East Bank approach by 25 feet to meet the future East Bank Boulevard, leaving the Woodland Street and Shelby Avenue bridges as the only two straight into downtown.

    TDOT

PAMPHLETEER TOOLS

THINGS TO DO

Tonight Mon, Nov 16

ShowVenueTimePriceLink
Ashley Monroe & Charlie WorshamStation Inn8p$30Info for Ashley Monroe & Charlie Worsham
Rock NiteSkinny Dennis8pFreeInfo for Rock Nite
Bluegrass Mondays with The Frank Evans BandDee's Lounge6p$10Info for Bluegrass Mondays with The Frank Evans Band
The Time Jumpers3rd and Lindsley8p$25.61Info for The Time Jumpers
Grateful MondayAcme Feed & Seed7pFreeInfo for Grateful Monday
Motown MondayThe 5 Spot9p$5Info for Motown Monday

Today's newsletter is brought to you by Davis Hunt, Megan Podsiedlik, and Camelia Brennan.

The rest of today's issue

Keep reading: free, just your email

You keep coming back. It's free; we only ask for your email.

Headlines, tools, development and tonight's shows are one step away. Tomorrow's Daily comes with it.

Newsletters

Comments

Bards join the discussion. Everyone can read it.

Like what we do? Forward us to a friend.

Members

Get in the roomYou're in the room

Bards get free, privileged admittance to Pamphleteer events, and a say in the comments under every story. The membership pays for The Pamphleteer's reporting, member features and events.

The Bard$50 a monthThat's you

Become a BardYour membership