Photo by Clay Banks / Unsplash

Intifada in the Council Chambers

The Daily · · 6 min read

Good afternoon, everyone. Today:

  1. "Inshallah," cries the public
  2. Baseball put on ice
  3. Memphis Hilton

Got a taste of my own medicine yesterday. After blaming the lawless Nashville roads on the lack of policing, I got a ticket for talking on the phone while driving on Charlotte.

Had no idea this was a law (seriously). Told the officer that if I’d known, I’d have put the phone down when I passed him and tried to hide it. He let out a big belly laugh and stroked me a ticket anyway. Not really my place to complain. I asked for this.

Onward.

“You may only speak about items that appear on the agenda” said Vice Mayor Angie Henderson, facing a gallery full of pro-Palestinian protesters during last night’s Metro council meeting, “and you may only speak about the item for which you signed up.” In July of last year, a state law took effect mandating municipalities to take comments from the public at every public meeting; since then, despite Metro Council’s rule limiting the conversations to agenda items, the 20-minute comment periods have been commandeered by activists.

“Settler colonialism is a system of racist violence that seeks to deprive indigenous people of their rights, their land, labor, and resources,” said Tristan Warner from the podium. According to the sign-up sheet, Warner was there to oppose a resolution renewing Rite of Passage’s contract with the county’s only juvenile detention facility. Once he took the mic, he launched into a rant regarding settler colonialist regimes, claiming both the United States and Israel are based on the “logic of genocide” before concluding with “Free, free Palestine.”  

Next up was Diluvio Palazzolo, a “trauma and decolonization psychologist” who was there to weigh in on a resolution recognizing May as Asian American, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander Heritage Month. Palazzolo told the body that they are obligated to honor the “heritage of resistance against colonization, occupation and imperialism” by standing with “Palestinian Americans who cry out for the end of genocide and occupation,” before attempting to passify the rule to stay on topic by tying his speech it back to the legislation: “Palestine is in Southwest Asia.”

Indeed, the majority of those who spoke during the public comment period were there to make a statement about Palestine, and the blatant takeover was the perfect segue into the council’s next order of business: an amendment to remove Rule 28’s limitations restricting the topics allowed for discussion. “What we’ve seen is individuals coming out and being very creative in using the agenda to speak to the council,” said sponsor Delishia Porterfield. “That has put our Vice Mayor in a precarious situation of having to determine if something is on the agenda.”

Though most members supported the change, a few had concerns: Councilmember Tom Cash observed that he sees the same people signing up to speak every month. Rules Committee Chair Sandra Sepulveda iterated that, regardless of the change, those who signed up to speak on actual agenda items would be prioritized. She took care to mention that she doesn’t anticipate anyone abusing or monopolizing the process.

On the other hand, Councilmember Rollin Horton wasn’t fully convinced; he expressed concerns that the change would create “a forum for bizarre, obscene, or hateful comments,” citing his observation of the recent neo-Nazi parade downtown. Councilmember Sheri Weiner then added a bit of pragmatism to the discussion, mentioning her concerns about those who use their time to discuss broad topics — topics the council has no authority to address. 

Ultimately, the council approved the rules change, as attendees holding “WE ARE NOT THE UNITED STATES OF ISRAEL” and “FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA” signs looked on from the gallery. One month from now, the public comment period will be open to any topic under the sun. After the vote, the majority of the pro-Palestine protesters exited the council chambers—small victory in hand. MEGAN PODSIEDLIK


⧖⧗⧖ SHOW YOUR SUPPORT ⧗⧖⧗

If you want to support The Pamphleteer, a recurring donation is the best way. We have a $10/month Grub Street tier and a $50/month Bard tier. Membership gets you access to our comments section and free access to upcoming events.

→ → BECOME A MEMBER ← ←

🧊 Baseball on Ice MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred threw the idea that Nashville could land a professional baseball franchise any time soon on ice. At his annual meeting with the Associated Press Sports Editors earlier this week, Manfred stated that he plans to have an expansion in place by 2029, when his term as commissioner ends.

But the delay is of less concern than Manfred's next declaration regarding the potential site of a new team: "We need an Eastern time zone and [a city in] either a Mountain or Western time zone just in terms of making the format work in the best possible way." Currently, there are fourteen teams in the Eastern time zone, eight teams in the Central time zone, two in the Mountain, and six in the Western. Relatedly, here’s an interesting infographic showing when games start for each MLB team based on their hometown time zone. DAVIS HUNT

🌸 Memphis Hilton Earlier this week, Governor Lee signed a bill that bans judges from factoring “ability to pay” into its bail calculator. As if to underscore the need for such a bill, last week in Memphis, a man out on bond for a January shooting hunted down and threatened a witness who testified against him. In celebration of the signing, Senate sponsor Brent Taylor (R-Memphis) used the opportunity to stump for Memphis’ status as Tennessee’s msot renowned city. “Together, we will make sure Memphis can seize its fullest potential,” wrote Taylor. “After all, Tennessee cannot be successful if its most famous city is not successful.” Most famous city? Really? DAVIS HUNT

🏭 Waller in the Holler This afternoon, a bunch of bored activists will gather at Lipscomb University to protest the TVA’s use of fossil fuels while the power company holds a listening session on campus. Organized by the Sierra Club, the protest is purportedly a response to the agency’s plan to construct eight natural gas plants. “Since 2020, TVA has planned eight gas plants across its region,” writes WPLN reporter Caroline Eggers, “equivalent to 20% of the utility’s operating capacity, and more than 160 miles of pipelines in Tennessee. TVA’s top six executives have collectively banked millions from the process.” Cue villain music.

The protest will be followed by the Rally for the Valley at Centennial Park, which includes a performance by musician Jonathan Singleton, a lecture from environmental activist Bill McKibben, and a Yas Kween hype speech from Rep. Aftyn Behn. DAVIS HUNT

The action status of other notable bills from last night's council meeting:

Rules of Procedure
  • Rule 28 (Passed) Expands the public comment period to any topic
  • Rule 43.1 Extends the automatic indefinite deferral of a bill from happening after four deferrals instead of three
  • Rule 43.4 (Deferred) Gives a one-meeting grace period after deferred legislation
Resolutions
  • RS2024-417 (Passed) Enhanced DUI and seatbelt enforcement
  • RS2024-424 (Passed) Approving an application for a Climate Pollution Reduction grant from the EPA
Bills on First Reading
  • BL2024-181 (Withdrawn) NEST; Building Code, firewalls, single staircase 
  • BL2024-187 (Deferred) NEST; allows construction of single-family, two-family, and multi-family in all commercial zones 
  • BL2024-343 (Passed) Adding a CM as board member of the Arts Commission 
  • BL2024-356 (Passed) Revised Flood Insurance Rate Map 
Bills on Second Reading (*also on public hearing)
  • BL2024-184 (Passed) NEST; DADUs, daycare centers, and mixed-use zones 
  • BL2024-303 (Withdrawn) Annual disclosures required for Metro boards and commission members 
  • BL2024-336 (Passed) Accelerating Resilience of the Community through Holistic Engagement and use of Renewables 
Bills on Third Reading
  • BL2024-179 (Passed) MNPD required to produce reports on use of excessive force
  • BL2024-182 (Passed) NEST; bathrooms, dryer hookups (amended), housekeeping
  • BL2024-301 (Passed) Fair Board rules 
  • BL2024-302 (Passed) Purpose of the Metropolitan Nashville Arts Commission to include “equity”
  • BL2024-305 (Passed) Sending back Pre-Columbian collection at Parthenon to Mexico

TODAY'S WEATHER

DEVELOPMENT

  • Site Work Begins On 600-acre, 68 Home Development In Franklin

    More Info
  • One of Nashville's largest office towers is on the market

    NBJ
  • Music Row property sells for $2.2M

    Post

THINGS TO DO

Tonight Wed, May 8

ShowVenueTimePriceLink
SlowdiveThe Caverns7p$59.50+Info for Slowdive
Neil Young & Crazy Horse: Love Earth TourFirstBank Amphitheater7:30p$90+Info for Neil Young & Crazy Horse: Love Earth Tour
Charles Butler & FriendsStation Inn8p$20Info for Charles Butler & Friends
The Marshall Tucker BandRyman Auditorium7:30p$49.50+Info for The Marshall Tucker Band
Bluegrass NightThe American Legion Post 827pFreeInfo for Bluegrass Night

The rest of today's issue

Keep reading: free, just your email

You keep coming back. It's free; we only ask for your email.

Headlines, tools, development and tonight's shows are one step away. Tomorrow's Daily comes with it.

Newsletters

Comments

Bards join the discussion. Everyone can read it.

Like what we do? Forward us to a friend.

Members

Get in the roomYou're in the room

Bards get free, privileged admittance to Pamphleteer events, and a say in the comments under every story. The membership pays for The Pamphleteer's reporting, member features and events.

The Bard$50 a monthThat's you

Become a BardYour membership