Via Nashville Public Library: Mayor Ben West’s Charter Commission, appointed by soon-to-be mayor Beverly Briley, working in the courthouse in 1962.

The Illusion of Choice

The Daily · · 7 min read

Good afternoon, everyone. Today:

  1. Metro’s Charter Revision Committee starts working out how to cut the council in half
  2. Federal judges in Nashville rule against ICE five times this month
  3. BNA quietly fired its police chief in September

Also today

Passage Press Comes to Town. Author TJ Harker and special guests in Nashville on Dec. 3 to celebrate the release of his book American Scapegoat: How a Corrupt Justice System Sacrificed Derek Chauvin to the Mob. Copy signed by the author included with purchase. (Buy Tickets)

Metro Council may seek voter approval for a decision already made by the courts: the body must shrink.

At Friday’s special-called Charter Revision Committee meeting, Metro Legal Director Tyler Yarbro said that, under her interpretation of state law and Metro Nashville’s charter, the council shouldn't reduce its membership to 20 seats through a resolution alone. Instead, she said, the change should require voters to approve a specific plan through a charter amendment. Yarbro said state law gives Metro flexibility to call a special election. She identified March 22, 2027, when candidate petitions open for the August races, as the key deadline for putting the question to voters. It remains unclear what would happen if voters reject the proposal.

Perhaps it’s easy to forget, given that the definition of “democracy” has become something of an evolving political talking point, that all American cities and counties are creatures of their states. Tennessee follows Dillon’s Rule, which limits local governments to the powers granted to them by the legislature. Metro Nashville ultimately answers to the state, and in November, the Tennessee Supreme Court unanimously upheld the state’s 20-member cap, ruling that the state constitution does not prevent the legislature from limiting the size of metro councils. Though Director Yarbro has advised putting the reduction to a vote, not everyone understands her advice or is convinced it is the correct legal course.

“That's an opinion that we got,” said Councilmember Courtney Johnston during yesterday’s Charter Revision meeting. “I think we are running a serious risk If we go to the ballot and theoretically, and maybe even probably, a reduction is voted down, and we're in a situation where we're electing a 40-member body in 2027, which the state will not recognize.”

“I'm still struggling with… fully understanding the direction of our law director,” admitted Councilmember Burkely Allen. Councilmember Brenda Gadd suggested bringing Yarbro back to the committee to answer questions. There is still no explanation as to what would happen if the council decides to hold a special public vote to shrink the council and Nashvillians say no.

Community Meetings

The committee did set five community sessions for December. Four will be held around the county on December 2, 3, 8 and 12. The council office is still choosing venues and was asked to avoid police precincts. The fifth, on December 7, will be a public hearing in the Council Chamber. The committee will meet again on November 30 to finalize a public survey, which the body hopes to release by December 2.

The council is still deciding three things. The first is how many seats to have: the state caps the council at 20, but nothing prevents it from being smaller, and some councilmembers noted that 20 is still too many. The second is how to split the seats between district and at-large members. Last term’s proposals included 17 district and 3 at-large, 15 and 5, or all 20 elected by district. The third is whether serving as a councilmember should become a full-time, full-salary job, which would affect pay, staffing, and who can afford to run.

SOMETHING TO DO

American Scapegoat: Derek Chauvin and the Future of the West, presented by Passage Press: Thursday, Dec. 3, 7pm, Nashville. Click for tickets.

📚 American Scapegoat release event Passage Press hosts author TJ Harker and special guests in Nashville on Thursday, Dec. 3, to celebrate the release of his book American Scapegoat: How a Corrupt Justice System Sacrificed Derek Chauvin to the Mob.

A panel will discuss the Chauvin trial and its impact on criminal justice and social life in the U.S. VIP guests get a private happy hour with the panel and the author at 6pm; general admission starts at 7pm, with a cocktail hour and signed books after the talk. The address comes with registration. (Tickets here)

HEADLINES

  • BNA quietly fired its police chief in September

    The airport authority fired Chief Beth Kreppein on Sept. 18, eight months after hiring the former FBI agent, citing “unacceptable behavior” and retaliation against an employee who had filed a harassment complaint against her. Kreppein was put on leave in August and returned later that month. COO Adam Floyd then told her not to “single out that employee,” and fired her after she tried to set up monthly meetings with the employee, with an HR witness. Kreppein, who has hired a lawyer and is weighing a suit, says she was punished “for raising legitimate public safety concerns.” The airport hasn’t said who now runs its police.

    Tennessean
  • The man charged in two Broadway assaults was barred from the Entertainment District

    Assistant District Attorney Jenny Charles said Jacques Odom was put on 11 months and 29 days of supervised probation on Oct. 9 for simple possession and ordered to stay off Broadway. He’s accused of punching Paul Batz, a sheepdog trainer from New York on his first visit to Nashville, twice in the head outside Silverbelly Distillery on Oct. 12, then, about 30 minutes later, punching an 80-year-old man who was left unconscious with a brain bleed and broken ribs. Odom, whose record goes back to 1998, is jailed without bond.

    WSMV
  • Federal judges in Nashville have ruled against ICE five times this month

    Judges have ordered two detainees released and blocked three deportations, several faulting ICE for denying bond hearings with arguments the courts have already thrown out. Judge Aleta Trauger freed a Cuban man held almost two weeks without a hearing. Judge Waverly Crenshaw ordered hearings within five days for two Russians arrested when they showed up for a scheduled check-in at the Nashville ICE office.

    WKRN
  • Blackburn picks a pediatrician turned Hill staffer to run the health department

    Governor-elect Marsha Blackburn named Dr. Karen Summar, a Navy veteran who spent more than a decade at Green Hills Pediatric Associates, to replace Health Commissioner John Dunn. Summar went on to be Sen. Chuck Grassley’s health policy director and, from 2018, director of health policy for the Senate Finance Committee. She’s Blackburn’s eighth pick for her administration; earlier this week Blackburn named Josh Smith, a former prisoner pardoned by President Trump in 2021 who went on to lead the Federal Bureau of Prisons, to run the Department of Correction.

    WSMV

MY TAX DOLLARS WENT TO WHAT?

💸 Today in My Tax Dollars Went to What? Creation Myths: Queer Southern Stories of Belonging & Becoming, courtesy of Metro Arts Nashville. The project received $15,750 via the department’s Thrive Grant program.

Two years ago, we covered then-Metro Arts Director Daniel Singh’s efforts to “return land, money, and resources” to “Indigenous, African, and Asian peoples” by expanding the Thrive program. You can read more about that here.

DEVELOPMENT

  • Via Now Next Mira Music Row launched sales for its 25 condos at 1100 16th Ave. S., a six-story project with homes priced from $1.2 million to more than $6 million.

    More Info
  • The Boring Co. signed its 40-year licensing deal with the Metro Nashville Airport Authority yesterday. Over 40 years, the airport gets $34 million in licensing fees, $600,000 for legal and engineering costs, and $5 per pickup and drop-off once the Loop runs, estimated to total $309 million for the duration of the deal. The Loop’s station will sit 22 feet from the terminal’s front door where taxi and limo pickup sit now.

    Tennessean
  • Crescent Communities filed the first renderings for Novel oneC1TY, a 313-unit luxury apartment building at 3 City Ave. in Midtown’s One City with a sand-volleyball social bar and rooftop pool, set to finish in 2029.

    NBJ
  • Barista Parlor and its roasting company filed for Chapter 11 on Oct. 21, 10 months after owner Andy Mumma closed the Germantown, Sylvan Supply and Hillsboro Village shops. The reorganization keeps the original East Nashville shop on Gallatin Avenue and the outposts at the W Hotel and BNA.

    Tennessean
  • Bearded Iris will close its Germantown taproom on Van Buren Street on Dec. 5 after 12 years, citing rising rent and property taxes. Its beers will remain available in stores, bars and restaurants.

    Post

PAMPHLETEER TOOLS

THINGS TO DO

Tonight Thu, Nov 19

ShowVenueTimePriceLink
Two Giants: Guerrero & BronfmanSchermerhorn Symphony Center7:30p$29+Info for Two Giants: Guerrero & Bronfman
L'RainThe Blue Room7p$26.60Info for L'Rain
Medium BuildBrooklyn Bowl8p$47Info for Medium Build
King BuffaloThe Basement East8p$33.49Info for King Buffalo
Bluegrass All-Star Night hosted by Gena BrittStation Inn9pInfo for Bluegrass All-Star Night hosted by Gena Britt
Open MicFox and Locke6:30pFreeInfo for Open Mic
Kelley's HeroesRobert's Western World6:30pFreeInfo for Kelley's Heroes

The rest of today's issue

Keep reading: free, just your email

You keep coming back. It's free; we only ask for your email.

Headlines, tools, development and tonight's shows are one step away. Tomorrow's Daily comes with it.

Newsletters

Comments

Bards join the discussion. Everyone can read it.

Like what we do? Forward us to a friend.

Members

Get in the roomYou're in the room

Bards get free, privileged admittance to Pamphleteer events, and a say in the comments under every story. The membership pays for The Pamphleteer's reporting, member features and events.

The Bard$50 a monthThat's you

Become a BardYour membership