A Tax Break Is a Promise. Tennessee’s Nonprofit Hospitals Must Keep It.

Opinion ·

Tennessee’s nonprofit hospitals get $415 million a year in tax breaks, and too many give back less. Lawmakers should make them show it, Floyd argues.

By Brian Floyd2 min read

Nonprofit hospitals in Tennessee receive around $415 million annually in tax breaks. In return, they promise to give back to communities through free care for eligible patients. Yet, this does not always happen. Many nonprofit hospitals report the value of charity care provided at inflated prices, or they provide significantly less care than what they received in tax breaks. Nonprofit status is supposed to mean something, but many hospitals are not living up to the name.

Twenty-nine percent of nonprofit hospitals in Tennessee received more in tax benefits than they spent on their communities between 2020 and 2022. They gave nearly $53 million less in care than they should have provided. The statewide shortfall is enough to wipe out medical debt for more than 80,000 of our fellow Tennesseans.

The shortfall is not occurring because these hospital systems are struggling. For example, Vanderbilt University Medical Center reported roughly $200 million a year in income, but accounted for about $25 million a year of Tennessee’s charity care gap.

Hospitals can also make the charity care they provide appear bigger than it actually was. Loose rules and poor enforcement allow hospitals to report charity care using inflated prices instead of the actual costs. A screening that costs $250 to provide could be counted at its $4,000 list price.

Tennessee is not alone in dealing with this. Nationally, 80% of nonprofit hospitals gave back less than they received in tax breaks, coming in $25.7 billion short. The ten hospitals with the largest gaps each reported at least $100 million in net income. When nonprofits do not hold to their commitments, local governments bring in less revenue, patients pay higher bills, vulnerable patients don’t get the care they need, and the taxpayers are left to cover the shortfall.

Many hospitals fail to even tell patients what the true cost of their medical care is. Federal rules have required hospitals to post their prices since 2021. However, the HHS Office of Inspector General estimated that 46% of hospitals were out of compliance. This means that patients cannot shop for value, compare prices, evaluate their care options, or catch an inflated bill when the price stays hidden until it shows up in their mailbox.

This month, Tennesseans made their voices heard when they chose Marsha Blackburn as our state’s next governor. Throughout her years of service to Tennessee, she has been a staunch advocate for healthcare reforms. When the new Republican supermajority convenes in January, lawmakers should prioritize two reforms.

First, the state should crack down on any and all fraud. Currently, Tennessee’s hospitals are not required to report to the state how patients apply for financial assistance. That needs to change. If a hospital gets a tax break, it should show the taxpayers what they receive in return. Hospitals that don’t should have to explain why that happened. Lawmakers must be willing to put their exemptions on the table.

Secondly, price transparency rules must be enforced. Being open and honest is fundamental to maintaining the public’s trust. Washington may have written the current rule, but Tennessee can make it stronger. Ohio and Oklahoma have already taken action to prevent hospitals that ignore the rules from pursuing a patient for collections. Tennessee should do the same. Families deserve to know the cost of care before they get the bill.

When hospitals fail to uphold their obligations, Tennessee families pay the price, as do the taxpayers. It’s time for lawmakers to deliver by holding hospitals accountable with these common-sense conservative reforms.

Brian Floyd serves as a board member of The Tennessee Conservatives Coalition.

The rest of the story

Keep reading: free, just your email

You keep coming back. It's free; we only ask for your email.

The rest is one step away, and the Daily comes with it every weekday afternoon.

Newsletters

Comments

Bards join the discussion. Everyone can read it.

Like what we do? Forward us to a friend.

Members

Get in the roomYou're in the room

Bards get free, privileged admittance to Pamphleteer events, and a say in the comments under every story. The membership pays for The Pamphleteer's reporting, member features and events.

The Bard$50 a monthThat's you

Become a BardYour membership